Skip to primary navigationSkip to main contentSkip to footer
  • Toggle Search Menu
  • (419) 782-4061
Stambaugh Jewelers logo
  • Toggle Search Menu
  • Toggle My Account Menu
    Forgot Password?

    Don't have an account? Sign up now

  • Toggle My Wishlist
  • Toggle Shopping Cart Menu
  • Engagement
    Shop Now
    Shop Engagement RingsGet Engaged TodayWomen's Wedding BandsMen's Wedding BandsAnniversary Gift GuideAntwerp DiamondsDiamond EducationLab-Grown Diamond EducationLooking for Something Custom?Wedding Planning Checklist
    Shop by Brand
    Allison KaufmanDoraGabriel & CoOstbyeRegoRomance
    Engagement at Stambaughs
    Engagement at Stambaughs
    Shop Gabriel & Co
    Shop Gabriel & Co

    Explore All Engagement
  • Women
    Shop by Category
    Fashion RingsPendantsEarringsBraceletsPearl JewelryWatchesWedding BandsGiftwareColored Gemstones
    Shop by Brand
    Allison KaufmanCharles GarnierChathamCitizen Eco DriveELLEGabriel & CoGalateaLuvente
    Imperial PearlsT. JazelleKendra ScottLafonnLeslie'sOstbye
    Shop Gabriel Fashion
    Shop Gabriel Fashion

    Explore All Women
  • Men
    Shop by Category
    RingsWatchesMen's JewelryColored Gemstones
    Shop by Brand
    OstbyeTokens and IconsINOXCitizen
    Shop Wedding Bands
    Shop Wedding Bands
    Shop All Men's
    Shop All Men's

    Explore All Men
  • Custom
  • Our Story
    About Us
    About Us
    Meet Our Team
    Meet Our Team
    What's Going On
    What's Going On
    To Antwerp
    To Antwerp

    Explore All Our Story
  • Jewelry Education
    Diamond EducationLab Grown Diamond EducationGemstone EducationJewelry CareEngagementsAnniversary GuidePrecious MetalsSpirit Gem Quiz
    Services
    Jewelry RepairWatch RepairEngravingPayment OptionsJewelry InsuranceAppraisal ServicesBuying & Selling GoldEar Piercing
    More
    Contact UsRefer a FriendWork For UsOur BlogSezzle: How It WorksEventsStambaugh CouplesTestimonialsAntwerp Diamond Trip
  1. Home
  2. Appraisal Services

Appraisal Services

Experiencing lost or damaged jewelry can be trying and appraising your jewelry before a situation occurs is extremely important. Our qualified jewelry and gem appraisers will evaluate your jewelry and provide a detailed description in determining a fair replacement value. There is no better tool to make sure your lost or damaged jewelry is replaced with comparable items. Each appraisal includes photographs and two reports, one for your insurance company and a duplicate copy for your records. Appraisal prices start at $125 per piece, but please stop in the store for details and pricing for your specific needs.

Stambaugh Jewelers works closely with several insurance companies to help resolve claims. You should always have the right to have your jewelry replaced by a jeweler you trust. We are available to contact your insurance provider and guide you with any replacement claims. The best way to make sure your jewelry is covered by insurance is to contact your agent, provide your appraisal and have it added to your homeowner’s insurance policy. Your insurance company can advise you. We also recommend contacting either Jewelers Mutual Insurance Company or Zillion . Both of their rates are very competitive and they provide insurance on jewelry exclusively. Many of our customers use Jewelers Mutual and Zillion and are pleased with the service and the coverage.

Estate Jewelry Sorting

Estate jewelry sorting is an additional service we offer at Stambaugh Jewelers. Often, estate jewelry will be a mix of fine jewelry and costume jewelry. Call to schedule a time to meet with us. We have helped numerous people in your situation evaluate their collections and determine what exactly they have. Whether you will hold on to these pieces to pass down through generations or you’ve decided to sell, we will be here to guide you.

We can help you:

  • know what is 'real' and what is costume jewelry,
  • know what should be appraised for insurance,
  • know rough ballpark values for distributing among heirs of an estate,
  • assess the condition of items that might require repair,
  • assess options to repurpose items in your collection to make them wearable,
  • gain value from your collection with an offer to buy or trade, all (or part) of your collection.
Fees are based on the time taken.

Scott identifying diamond characteristics

Downtown Defiance
512 Clinton Street
Defiance, OH 43512
(419) 782-4061
Store Information
Services
  • Jewelry Repair
  • Engraving
  • Financing
  • Appraisals
  • Gold Buying
  • Ear Piercing
  • Custom Jewelry Design
Information
  • FAQs
  • Refer a Friend
  • Join Our Team
  • Blog
  • Return & Shipping Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
Designers
  • Allison Kaufman
  • Belle Etoile
  • Charles Garnier Paris
  • Citizen Eco Drive
  • Gabriel & Co
  • Imperial Pearls
  • Kendra Scott
  • Luvente
  • Romance Diamond
  • T. Jazelle
Jewelry
  • Anniversary Gift Ideas
  • Birthday Gift Ideas
  • Gifts Under $500
  • Gifts Under $1000
  • Religious Jewelry
  • Staff Favorites
  • Graduation Gift Ideas
  • Father's Day Gift Ideas
  • Mother's Day Gift Ideas
  • Engagement Rings
  • Wedding Bands
  • Fashion Rings
  • Pendants
  • Earrings
  • Pearl Jewelry
  • Bracelets
  • Watches
  • Men's Fashion
  • Childrens Jewelry
  • Mother's Jewelry
  • Giftware
  • Kendra Scott
  • GIA
  • IJO
  • RJO
  • JOA
  • Jewelers Mutual
  • IJO
  • IJO

© 2025 Stambaugh Jewelers. All Rights Reserved. Website designed, maintained, and hosted by Punchmark. Accessibility Statement.

Learn how we use cookies in our Privacy Policy or manage cookie preferences.